Description
Historical empty200 does not prove complete positive visibility or no required action. Verify action/scope and existing positive control before implementation. Owner decision GCI-0041 (product read scope approval) is conditional future authority, not a customer grant or loop9 implementation admission. Packet 10 in codex/loop9-evidence/L-fam/packets.md (sha256 e46afeb70fca8cd53ee0843c898c810a80cc05bc4238db02d8df2c6310eac6ad) holds exact routes/pairs, exclusions and outstanding witnesses.
Acceptance Criteria
- #1 Fresh authorised dev evidence establishes exact action/scope pairs, permitted route/method and complete count visibility, or records the precise blocker without widening authority
- #2 Any implemented source emits counts and bounded enums only; sensitive sentinels are absent from payloads, logs, errors and persisted envelopes; unavailable coverage remains absent
- #3 Any implementation follows fresh inventory, exact selected read boundaries and offline public-boundary proofs with final just check and hosted CI; conditional blockers in the packet are resolved before build
Definition of Done
- #1 just test
- #2 just tf-validate
- #3 just check-identifiers and just no-em-dashes both return clean
Implementation Plan
R-wit freshdeclaredplaylists:read emptyscope basicNone exactGET /api/playlists versusAdminpositivecount/population orpreciseemptyblocker, no playlistcreation/dashboardsgrant; IDteardown.
Loop11 R-wit positive exactplaylists:read empty scope None/AdminHTTP200 count1 same UID/control visible; baselineNone also positive on this deployed version. Preserve conservative declared read pair, no universal minimality claim. L-fam a1 defaultoff playlists T2 count-only with immediate content/identity drops, no series; gated candidate holds push until explicit root permit after release mutex.
Implementation Notes
Loop10 exactplaylists:read emptyscope None/AdminGET200count0; no positiveexistingplaylist control, empty equalitycannotprove positivevisibility/completeness. SA67/roleeg016wk99qcqoe/token77deletedtoken-role-SA200/404/postlistsabsence. No creationgrant orimplementationadmitted, implementation0/reviewrepair0/infra0. Resume needsexistingpositivecontrol allowedrobk+matchingreader/Adminfullvisibility.
Witness SA69 token79 rolefg03zhahb65fke playlistbg03zh9jvj2tcc recorded-ID deletions200/404, postcount0/objectsabsent. Evidence codex/loop11-evidence/R-wit/GCI-0083/ledger.json. L-fam-GCI-0083 admitted a1, sharedfilesexclusive; no customer enabled reader grant inferred.
Final Summary
Loop11 accepted af309ea2f1565c0b7499fe382a3c833a84be9f2e exactCI37126599295allfourjobs success. Defaultoffplaylists/exactreadpair/GETcollection/countonly,200emptyzero/206unavailable/defaultoff0calls/liveinventory/publicS3/dashboardprivacyproof. Finalrebasejustcheck1966pass2skips8698subtestsTF/identifierpass; CR17/17complete0 onearlier4cfc componenttree, all17pathsblobidenticalafterrebase; independentAstra sourcePASS135tests/1536permissioncombos andcorrected-evidenceSupplementPASS. PositiveNone/Admincontrol1/IDteardownverified, baselineNonepositiveonlydeployedversion notuniversalminimality. a1/a2blockedroot-ownedseams,a3rootrescueaccepted,infra0; INPUT27+8plannedprovenanceseries,zero newproductmetrics; immutablelegacygoldenpreserved withliteralretirementpair. Notinsignedv0.6norenabledoneitherdeployment thisloop.