Description
Historical exact-None reader counters success exists. Owner accepts permission breadth to secret-bearing configuration, but collector must call counters only; list/retrieve routes stay excluded. Owner decision GCI-0041 (product read scope approval) is conditional future authority, not a customer grant or loop9 implementation admission. Packet 1 in codex/loop9-evidence/L-fam/packets.md (sha256 e46afeb70fca8cd53ee0843c898c810a80cc05bc4238db02d8df2c6310eac6ad) holds exact routes/pairs, exclusions and outstanding witnesses.
Acceptance Criteria
- #1 Fresh authorised dev evidence establishes exact action/scope pairs, permitted route/method and complete count visibility, or records the precise blocker without widening authority
- #2 Any implemented source emits counts and bounded enums only; sensitive sentinels are absent from payloads, logs, errors and persisted envelopes; unavailable coverage remains absent
- #3 Any implementation follows fresh inventory, exact selected read boundaries and offline public-boundary proofs with final just check and hosted CI; conditional blockers in the packet are resolved before build
Definition of Done
- #1 just test
- #2 just tf-validate
- #3 just check-identifiers and just no-em-dashes both return clean
Implementation Plan
Loop10 positive robk exact-pair projected-counter witness releases L-fam-0074; default-off irm-integrations token, T2 point-in-time count input/view, no metrics/customer grant. Failing-first minimized public-boundary proof, final-rebase just check/CodeRabbit/exact CI lane-owned.
a2 fixes the witnessed budget/input-label failures, keeps original fixture formatting, validates selected full run_t2 with real gatherer and process-edge fakes, consumes final explicit compose coverage API after origin update, then final gate/CodeRabbit/exact CI.
Implementation Notes
R-wit loop10 positive: None SA exact integrations-read empty scope plus IRM plugin access; reader/Admin GET counter-map both200, count25 equal; effective pairs only desired plus Grafana sharedwithme metadata. Token70, roleeg00skpl5q41sd, SA60 all deleted by recorded IDs; role/SA404 and postlists prove absence. Evidence codex/loop10-evidence/R-wit/GCI-0074/ledger.json. No minimality/subtract-one claim or customer grant.
Loop10 implementation a1 consumed infra0: final just check failed4+2errors (INPUT count19 vs20 and missing INPUT_LABELS), candidate manifest46b2d79ead4ad96e23735696b1133a50c98c2475398488d93e6bedc06d041724 retained uncommitted. Root grants a2 bounded repair: INPUT cardinality/generated BUDGET, bounded label, incidental fixture formatting cleanup, actual T2/public boundary after explicit coverage API. No new metric. a3/a4 remain within four-attempt ceiling.
R-fam round1 confirms CRmajor1/3 VALID: absent optional IRM view raises FileNotFoundError before entire Usage build. Major2/4 hide/delete remedy INVALID against last-good contract, alternative optoutdisplay policy outofscope. Root review-repair GCI-0074-r1 reserved: guard only new panel/tab using existing viewsource, trueabsence omitted/retainedviewincluded, otherfailures explicit; rebaseonSyntheticinput/cardinality21. a1/a2consumed, infra1, implementationa3/a4unused; no new sharedstorage/delete/scope rights.
Reviewrepairr1 stopped on actual6shared rebaseconflicts preserved stash/patch. Root resolved exactSynthetic+IRM import/param/calls/gatherers/validation/docs union without changingSyntheticsemantics; originalexplicittriple channel retained. Root corrected newlyauthoredoverbroadmissingpanel test to inspect actualtable/tab, retainingsharedfreshnessage. r2 REVIEWREPAIR reserved for integrationvalidation/cardinality21/generator/CRcandidate, implementationa3/a4notused, no mainpushduringreleasefreeze.
r2 reviewrepairconsumed infra0: gate1733pass1failure2skips8156subtests, CRcomplete20/20 zero findings. New admittedIRM retirementpairs conflict upstreamoldSyntheticremovablegolden; read-only8cases diagnostic proves desired/dangerous/zero discoveryunchanged andexacttwoextraIRMremovablepairs. Two roundsfoundnew integrationdefects so rootcommissions wholecomponentinventoryreview before finalr3; no goldensrewritten or blanketpermissionsfiltered.
Wholecomponentinventory30a213e2 found only reproducedoldremovableuniverse assertion, no additional runtimebug; all20paths/fixturelifecycle reviewed, 27familytests/119integrationtests852subtests/8completegoldencases support literal2pairunion. Root takes bounded final GCI-0074-r3 REVIEWREPAIR, extends ONLY testexpectedremovable by two independently literalIRMretirementpairs, keeps originalgolden/desired/dangerous/both0discovery/probe/norepairunchanged; finalrebase/gate+changedtestsliceCR. r3lastreviewallowance, no implementationcountreset.
New independent count-integrity finding: valid HTTP206 body is accepted by response.ok and may publish a partial inventory as complete. Real guarded-client offline reproduction established; no live206 observed. Existing3 review-repair rounds exhausted, so no fourth repair authorised. Separate follow-up recorded but NOT admitted/resettingbudget; prior exact200 witness/code/CI remains historical proof, entry nowParked pending explicit allowance.
Final Summary
Loop10 exactNone/Adminrobk counterGET25equality+IDteardown, minimized selectedfullT2->compose->S3/panel proof, optionalneverpublishedguard/retainedolderview/nohiddenerrors, exact2pairretirementgoldencompatibility. Landed30f555b125c7e7b5c9a07f695aa9a17a40118659 CI37043315992success; finalgate1734pass2existing skips8156subtests/CRcomplete21one redundantparseminorleft withevidence; independentcomponentinventory+securityPASS. a1/a2implementationconsumed, reviewrepairr1-r3consumed, infra1. No customergrant/deployedfamilycollector/livebrowser claim.
Loop11 GCI-0087 (reject partial IRM responses) accepted under separately granted D-IRM11 allowance; closes the remaining HTTP206 blocker at5e132bed12cfa71cadd4eeaad78300d454e89f6a CI37120735853success and independentfocusedreviewPASS. Historical GCI-0074 attempt/review consumption preserved, not reset. No customerfamily rollout or live206 claim.